Complimentary insured UK deliveryMade in CornwallSustainable choicesLab grown diamonds & recycled goldComplimentary insured UK deliveryMade in CornwallSustainable choicesLab grown diamonds & recycled gold
Rosalind Elunyd

Journal · 22 November 2026

What Is the Most Ethical Form of Gold?

Why I use recycled gold, and what other options are available to you

What Is the Most Ethical Form of Gold?

When choosing an engagement ring or wedding band, it's easy to focus on the design, the gemstones and the colour of the gold. But have you ever thought about where the gold itself comes from?

Gold mining can have a significant impact on the natural environment, as well as on the people and communities involved in its extraction. There are several ways to source gold more responsibly, and I've given quite a bit of thought to the choices I make for my jewellery.

I choose recycled gold as my starting point, but I also offer an alternative for customers who would prefer to know exactly where their gold was mined. Here's a little more about the options and why I choose to work with them.

What makes gold ethical?

I think there are two important things to consider when looking at the ethics of gold: its environmental impact and the way people are treated throughout its supply chain.

Gold mining can involve clearing land, disturbing habitats, using large quantities of water and producing waste that can pollute the surrounding environment. The energy needed to extract and process gold also contributes to its environmental footprint.

Then there's the human side. Working conditions, fair pay, health and safety, human rights and the treatment of local and Indigenous communities all matter.

These issues aren't necessarily addressed together. A mine might have good employment practices but still have a considerable environmental impact. And while recycled gold avoids the need for new extraction, its recycled status alone doesn't tell us everything about its original source.

Recycled gold: making use of what we already have

Recycled gold is my preferred choice and the starting point for the jewellery I make.

Gold is a wonderful material to work with because it can be melted down, refined and made into something new without losing its essential properties. It offers the same quality as newly mined metal.

Recycled gold can come from old jewellery, manufacturing offcuts and other recovered gold-bearing materials. The recycled gold I use is professionally refined before casting, ensuring its quality is just as good as any other type of gold. By using this existing material, we can reduce the need for newly mined gold and keep a valuable resource in circulation.

I love the idea that the gold in a new ring might once have been part of another piece of jewellery. It could have been worn for years, tucked away in a jewellery box or eventually melted down to become something completely different.

There is one thing worth bearing in mind: recycled gold isn't automatically free from every ethical concern. Its recycled status tells us that the material has been recovered for reuse, but it doesn't necessarily tell us where it was originally mined or the conditions under which it was extracted. The way recycled gold is sourced and handled still matters.

My reason for choosing it is primarily environmental. It makes sense to me to use the gold we've already mined rather than create further demand for extraction. Additionally, the full process of recycling gold produces less in carbon emissions than newly mined gold - even the ones investing heavily in renewable energies.

SMO Gold: knowing where your gold comes from

I can also offer Single Mine Origin (SMO) Gold for customers who would prefer gold with a traceable origin.

SMO Gold is sourced from a named mine and kept separate through its supply chain, rather than being mixed with gold from multiple sources. Each batch has its own identity and QR code, allowing its origin to be traced.

The SMO Gold I can offer comes from the Bellevue Gold Mine in Western Australia. This means you can know where the gold was mined and access information about the mine's environmental and social performance. Bellevue has invested in renewable energy, including wind and solar power. Its sustainability reporting also records net zero Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions for the first half of 2025, using renewable energy and carbon offsets for remaining emissions.

I think this is an interesting alternative because it offers a level of transparency that isn't always possible with gold from more mixed supply chains. You can look into the specific mine and find out about its approach to environmental management, employment, health and safety, and its relationship with local communities.

Of course, knowing exactly where gold comes from doesn't mean that mining has no environmental impact. It's still newly extracted gold, and there are impacts associated with that - you can see photos of the mine in production, and whilst the mine has plans in place to regenerate the environment once mining ceases, the environmental impact still exists.

What about Fairtrade and Fairmined gold?

You may also come across Fairtrade Gold and Fairmined Gold. Both schemes focus on improving conditions for people working in artisanal and small-scale mining.

They have standards covering areas such as working conditions, environmental practices and traceability. They also aim to ensure that mining communities receive greater economic benefits from the gold they produce.

Fairmined offers an additional option called Ecological Gold, which has stricter environmental requirements, including avoiding toxic chemicals and rehabilitating native ecosystems.

These schemes are particularly interesting if supporting smaller mining organisations and improving the livelihoods of miners is important to you. They still involve extracting new gold, but aim to make that extraction more responsible.

So, which should you choose?

It really depends on what matters most to you.

If your main concern is reducing the need for further mining, recycled gold is a very good choice. It's the option I prefer because I believe we should make better use of the precious resources we already have.

If you'd rather know exactly where your gold was mined, SMO Gold offers traceability back to the Bellevue Gold Mine, along with information about its environmental and social practices.

Fairtrade and Fairmined are worth exploring if you'd particularly like your purchase to support smaller mining communities and better working conditions.

I wouldn't claim that one option is automatically the most ethical in every respect. They address different concerns, and there are trade-offs with each. What's important is understanding what you're choosing and why.

The gold I use in my jewellery

I use recycled gold as my standard choice because, as far as I'm concerned, it makes sense to use the gold we've already mined before extracting more. It's a valuable material that can be reused again and again, so I don't see the need to start with newly mined gold every time.

However, I understand that some customers would rather know exactly where their gold came from. That's why I can also offer SMO Gold from the Bellevue Gold Mine as an alternative.

I don't expect everyone to make the same choice as me. I simply want to be open about where the materials come from and give customers the information to decide what feels right for them.

When you're choosing a piece of jewellery that you hope to wear for many years, I think it's worth giving some thought to the gold it's made from, as well as the design.

Have a piece in mind? I'd love to hear about it.

More from the journal